A Season of Family Dysfunction or Just Individual Differences? How to Find Your Peace of Mind In Family Gatherings

December is here, a month filled with twinkling lights, festive gatherings, and the spirit of giving. Can you feel it? It's also a time when family takes center stage. While the holidays often portray images of picture-perfect families enjoying warmth and abundance (see below 😋), the reality for many is far more nuanced.

If you come from a dysfunctional family, naturally, the longing for that idealized image can be especially strong. But the truth is, no family is perfect. Relationships are complex, and navigating them can be challenging, especially in today's world where differences of opinion seem to widen with every passing day.

It's easy to feel alone when those closest to you seem unable or unwilling to understand your perspective. During the holidays, when family tensions often run high, it can be particularly difficult to discern whether your particular challenges stem from individual differences or deeper-rooted family dysfunction. I hope this email will help you know what's what and how to protect your peace of mind regardless.

Understanding Individual Differences

In families without dysfunction, individual differences can lead to disagreements, but they navigate these differences through respectful conversations - i.e. each person can express their perspectives without resorting to personal attacks. Healthy families acknowledge and accept differing priorities and lifestyles, focusing on maintaining connection. By respecting each other's autonomy and choices, they avoid imposing their views on others. These families model that relationships can thrive even amidst diverse opinions. Here are two examples:

Differing Political Views

• Sibling 1: "I just don't understand how you can support that candidate. Their policies go against decades of progress!"
• Sibling 2: "I know we see things differently, but I really believe they have the best economic plan. And I don't think the other candidate is any better either."
• Sibling 1: "We clearly have different priorities. To me, human rights are more important than the economy. Maybe we can agree to disagree on politics for now."
• Sibling 2: "Sure! Look, I love you, even if we don't see eye to eye on politics. Can we talk about this another time? Did you see the letter Amy wrote to Santa? Isn't it cute?"

​​Different Parenting Styles

• Grandparent: "You're letting him get away with that? When you were his age, you knew better than to talk back to me!"
• Parent: "Mom, I appreciate your input, but I'm trying a different approach with my kids. I think it's important for them to express themselves, even if they disagree."
• Grandparent: "Well, I just hope you don't regret it when he's a teenager!"
• Parent: "I know you're coming from a place of love, and I value your experience. But I need to parent in a way that feels right for me and my family."

A respectful conversation ends where family members, though perhaps not in agreement, cease trying to force their perspective on others. While a moment of discomfort may arise, the tension quickly dissipates. However, in dysfunctional families, this tension lingers due to the persistent violation of individual boundaries.

Understanding Family Dysfunction

Dysfunctional family systems often require a different approach – one that prioritizes self-preservation and healthy boundaries. Here are some key indicators of dysfunctional family systems:

• Distorted Communication: Communication becomes a power struggle where one person or group dominates, employing tactics like yelling, blaming, and withdrawing to maintain control. Open and respectful expression of feelings is rare and usually ends in consequences.
• Enmeshment and Boundary Violations: Individuality is blurred, with a sense of "I am you, and you are me, we're one family." It leads to over-involvement in each other's lives and a disregard for personal autonomy. The opposite, disengagement and emotional distance/withdrawing emotional closeness and affection as a way to control and establish power is also a sign of dysfunction.
• Chronic Conflict Avoidance: Problems are consistently swept under the rug, preventing resolution and fostering resentment and tension.
• Rigid Roles: Family members get locked into limiting roles (the hero, the scapegoat, the peacemaker), hindering personal growth and any possibility of change.
• Control and Manipulation: Manipulation tactics like guilt trips, shame, gaslighting, and emotional blackmail are used to maintain power and control over others.
• Lack of Empathy and Scapegoating: A lack of empathy and understanding for each other's emotional needs is common. Often, responsibility for family problems is shifted onto the most vulnerable members or the one/s who deviate from the family roles.

While overt signs like neglect, shunning, and abuse clearly necessitate separation and healing, the more subtle dynamics of dysfunction can be equally damaging. Unlike families who prioritize connection while respecting individuality, dysfunctional families prioritize control and suppress individual expression, creating an environment where healthy emotional growth is impossible. As a result, spending time with a dysfunctional family can be traumatizing, and require more mental and emotional resources. However, there are ways how you can protect yourself and mitigate the potential harm.

Tips on How to Protect Your Peace of Mind

It goes without saying how important it is to prioritize your well-being, especially during the holidays. This time is for you. Therefore, you and you alone get to decide how you want to spend it, and whether you want to include your family or not.

Here are some tips to help you navigate challenging family dynamics:

1. Communicate your needs clearly and respectfully. Be brave to say "no" to requests that drain you or cross your boundaries. Some families like to test boundaries to see how much power they can exert, and some simply will not tolerate them. In that case, your holiday plans may be dictated by your family.
   
2. Always have an exit plan. While with your family, make time for activities that nourish you. This might include exercise, a sauna, spending time in nature, engaging in hobbies you love, or simply enjoying some alone time away from everyone.
3. Lean on trusted friends, a therapist, or a support group. Sharing your experiences and feelings can be incredibly validating and empowering. You may see teenagers on their phones or computers during family gatherings—they're coping, and so can you.
4. Look for shared interests or values. Even small points of agreement can help bridge the gap. Remember that you can always troll your family by pretending to agree with them about everything. This way, they won't have anything to criticize, and you can enjoy the game.
5. There is a benefit to temporarily empathize with your family. It helps you relate, even if that empathy and understanding aren't reciprocated. Remember that this is temporary, and you can return to hating their guts after the holiday. That's what many families often do anyway.  

Remember that the holiday season can be a joyous time, but it can also be emotionally charged. If you feel more stress and anxiety than joy and excitment, it's okay, you're not weird, have some rest. Preserve your energy for the things that are important to you.

I hope that knowing the difference between individual disagreements and family dysfunction can help you accurately assess your particular situation, assign responsibility appropriately, and maintain your peace of mind in the heat of the moment. I wish you a brave Christmas!

‍

Disclaimer: This blog post is the result of a collaboration between human creativity and AI assistance. While the core ideas and insights are my own, I used AI to refine the text and enhance the overall quality.